For those who don't know, Eugenia Cooney is a young self-proclaimed 'emo' YouTuber who makes videos about clothes, makeup and the like. She's also incredibly thin. Like, almost unbelievably thin.
See what I mean?
Recently, she has attracted enormous amounts of attention from both the online world and the real one. There have been movements to try and help her and even petitions trying to ban her from YouTube.
Another YouTuber, who goes by the name Onision, has recently been devoting a lot of attention to her. Almost borderline-obsessive amounts of attention. His videos started out very concerning, claiming he wants to help Eugenia but then (I assume because he failed to garner any attention from her back) the videos quickly turned malicious. He made fun of her body, her diet -- which we know nothing about -- and generally belittled eating disorders and those who suffer from it.
Eugenia's YouTube popularity has soared in the last couple of months with heaps upon heaps of new subscribers, however, many of her viewers are trolls who leave abhorrent comments on her videos and there has been a massive spike of dislikes on her videos. More recently, there's even been a petition, started by Onision I believe, to ban her from YouTube entirely, their reasoning behind that being that her physical appearance is a bad and damaging influence on young and impressionable girls who may be watching.
There's only one thing I can say to all of this: leave her alone! First of all, we don't know if she even has anorexia nervosa (though it is likely) as she has neither confirmed nor denied the rumours. However, even if she does have anorexia, it's unfair and unethical to ban her from YouTube. That would mean taking away her income, her livelihood and her hobby. Especially since moving out of her mum's place into her own apartment, YouTube is how she makes her living and you cannot deny someone their job because of their appearance. We don't ban people for having an illness, even an eating disorder. In that case, we should also be petitioning to ban Boogie2988 from YouTube too! But there is no petition for that. Instead, we get this poor girl being attacked for her appearance. I should also note that banning her from YouTube would do absolutely nothing to help her anorexic mindset, if she has it. If anything, it would make her worse.
One of the main justifications for the petition is that Eugenia is potentially harming other people, specifically young girls who may look to her as 'thinspiration' or 'thinspo'. Firstly, it's not just young girls who suffer from eating disorders. Also, if people are looking to her as inspiration and encouragement to lose weight, then they're probably not all that healthy-minded to begin with and they most likely already have some form of disordered eating.
Furthermore, it hasn't even been confirmed that Eugenia has anorexia or any other eating disorder. Her medical history is none of our business and she has every right not to disclose any of it to strangers on the internet.
In my opinion, people should just leave her alone. Politely ask her to get help if she needs it, if you must, but don't attack her, leave dislikes on her videos or sign the petition. It'll only end up doing more harm than good. Leave her health to herself, her friends and family around her and medical professionals.
Navigating Minds
Friday, 6 January 2017
Thursday, 5 January 2017
My Diagnoses
(Content warning: mention of lowest weight, self-harm, trauma,
suicide)
I guess I should start off this mental-health focused blog
by telling you about my mental health. Specifically, my diagnoses. On this
blog, I will be sharing my experience of multiple mental illnesses, my opinions
on controversial topics, and help for friends and family whose loved ones have
any sort of mental illness themselves.
When I was 14, I was diagnosed with severe Anorexia Nervosa
(restricting subtype). I probably had the illness for around six months prior
to this. I was always slightly underweight as a child and a young teenager but just
before my fourteenth birthday, my weight plummeted down to 40kg (6.2
stone/88lbs). I was tall for my age too and this put my BMI at a dangerous
14.2. This was after I had gained at least 3kg after being scared into ‘recovery’.
I estimate my lowest BMI to be around 13-14. I was in the 1st/2nd
BMI percentile in weight for others of my age. To put this into perspective, a
healthy BMI is 18-25 and to be considered a healthy weight, and in percentiles,
you should be above the 5th and less than the 85th.
According to others, I looked emaciated.
On a daily basis, I was asked (by complete strangers!) if I was
‘anorexic’, to which I stammered and hurriedly walked away in response. At my
worst, I used to skip breakfast, using the excuse that I didn’t have time to
eat it. Then, at lunch, I gave away my food to my concerned friends or, if they
refused to take it, I’d simply throw it away. When I got home from school, I’d
switch on the Wii and play Just Dance obsessively for hours on end. The game
started out as just a bit of fun but I quickly became enraptured in the thrill
of burning calories and I rode that exercise and hunger high. At dinner, I would
eat as little as possible and I’d eat in my room and away from prying eyes. If I
was feeling particularly nervous about eating, I’d hide away food in cupboards,
bathroom bins or even out a window and into a bush. In the evening, I remember browsing
pro-ana sites, staring at ‘thinspiration’ and googling how long it takes to
starve to death.
I don’t remember being suicidal or even depressed but I must
have been unhappy to be searching how to die at the age of fourteen. In addition
to this, I had started self-harming. I don’t know why I started. All I remember
was that one day, I took a pair of nail scissors and I ran the sharp point over
my arm again and again until it bled. This I kept to myself for a very long
time. My parents already knew about my anorexia and I didn’t want them to find
out about this. I wanted it to be mine. My own secret. However, they discovered
it eventually (while we were on holiday in America; I was on the beach and not
careful enough to hide my cuts) and immediately brought me to see the child
psychiatrist who diagnosed me with moderate major depression.
At the same time as this, I had begun to experience crippling
anxiety and, around once a week, a full-blown panic attack. This would be over
social situations, going out into town, buying something from the shops. The mere
thought of having to interact with a stranger terrified me. During my panic
attacks, I would be convinced that I was having a heart attack, dying, or in
some other serious danger. Despite my blindness to my anorexia and depression, I
immediately suspected some sort of anxiety disorder. I googled and searched
online for symptoms and sub-types and found social anxiety disorder. I mentioned
it to my therapist during one of my sessions who told my psychiatrist and there
I received my diagnosis of generalised (not social) anxiety.
A few years later, after my initial stint in the mental
health services, I was discharged. However, not long after I left, I began to
hear voices. Small whispers that would say my name over and over again. I also
started to think very oddly about situations. I thought that there were cameras
in the trees hidden at my school and that the government was watching me
through the webcam of my laptop. Eventually, it progressed to hidden cameras in
my room and mind control through the wifi. I told this to my psychiatrist
during a medication review and she promptly referred me to the Early
Intervention for Psychosis team whose doctor diagnosed me with experiencing a
psychotic episode. It’s interesting to note here that I still haven’t been
formally diagnosed with any psychotic disorder, such as schizophrenia or
schizoaffective. I have no idea why.
Fast-forward several years later. I’m eighteen years old and
my anxiety is gone and my psychosis in remission. I still have depression and
anorexia nervosa. I had accepted my lot with that and I thought that would be
that. No more nasty surprises. Or so I thought. During my first month of university,
I had my first ever flashback. I never had one before but I knew instantly that
was what it was. I thought that the trauma that had happened to me was
happening all over again, I thought I was back in London, back with the
childminder. When it was over, I was very much shaken up which lasted for
several days. I told my care co-ordinator and eventually a doctor. She didn’t
formally diagnose me as that was the first time in meeting her but she
suggested that I had some form of post-traumatic stress.
This made sense to me as I was also searching the internet
for something else. Borderline Personality Disorder (or BPD). For a while, I had
suspected that I had a personality disorder. It was only after meeting someone
else with BPD that everything fell into place. My issues with abandonment,
overattachment, impulsiveness, sensitivity to rejection or criticism. People
who suffer from borderline also report high rates of sexual abuse, eating
disorders, and self-harm. I discussed the possibility of having BPD with my mum
who dismissed my questioning, saying ‘I’m not severe enough, like your aunt, to
have BPD’. Two suicide attempts later and she agreed with me. We both brought
it up with my care co-ordinator who said it was ‘highly likely’ and would be ‘unsurprising’
if I had borderline personality disorder. That was last week. Now I have an
appointment with the psychiatrist coming up and we’re all going to bring it up
with them. Whether I get diagnosed or not, we shall see.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)